We move from our legacy way of interpreting ReplyChannelRange messages
which was incorrect. Previously, we'd rely on the Complete field of the
ReplyChannelRange message to determine when our peer had sent all of
their replies. Now, we properly adhere to the specification by
interpreting the block ranges of these messages as intended.
Due to the large number of nodes deployed with the previous method, we
still maintain and detect when we are communicating with them, such that
we are still able to sync with them for backwards compatibility.
It's not possible to send another reply once all replies have been sent
without another request. The purpose of the check is also done within
another test, TestGossipSyncerReplyChanRangeQueryNoNewChans, so it can
be removed from here.
In order to properly adhere to the spec, when handling a
QueryChannelRange message, we must reply with a series of
ReplyChannelRange messages, that when consumed together cover the
entirety of the block range requested.
In this commit we fix in a bug in `lnd` that could cause other
implementations which implement a strict version of the spec to
disconnect when trying to sync their channel graph using the gossip
query feature. Before this commit, we would embed the request to a
`QueryChannelRange` in the response, causing some clients to reject the
response as the `FirstBlockHeight` and `NumBlocks` field would be
identical for each chunk of the response.
In order to remedy this, we now properly set these two fields with each
returned chunk. Note that even after this commit, we keep our existing
behavior surrounding the `Complete` field as is. Otherwise, current
`lnd` clients which rely on this field (rather than the two
aforementioned fields) wouldn't be able to properly detect when a set of
responses to their query was "complete".
Partially fixes#3728.
Prior to this change, the numQueryResponses that we calculated would be
one more than what we actually wanted since it didn't account for the
initial QueryChannelRange msg. This resulted in the test sending one
extra delayed query than was configured. This doesn't fundamentally
impact the test, but does make what happens in the test more reflective
of the configuration.
This commit makes all replies in the gossip syncer synchronous, meaning
that they will wait for each message to be successfully written to the
remote peer before attempting to send the next. This helps throttle
messages the remote peer has requested, preventing unintended
disconnects when the remote peer is slow to process messages. This
changes also helps out congestion in the peer by forcing the syncer to
buffer the messages instead of dumping them into the peer's queue.
This commit creates a distinct replyHandler, completely isolating the
requesting state machine from the processing of queries from the remote
peer. Before the two were interlaced, and the syncer could only reply to
messages in certain states. Now the two will be complete separated,
which is preliminary step to make the replies synchronous (as otherwise
we would be blocking our own requesting state machine).
With this changes, the channelGraphSyncer of each peer will drive the
replyHanlder of the other. The two can now operate independently, or
even spun up conditionally depending on advertised support for gossip
queries, as shown below:
A B
channelGraphSyncer ---control-msg--->
replyHandler
channelGraphSyncer <--control-msg----
gossiper <--gossip-msgs----
<--control-msg---- channelGraphSyncer
replyHandler
---control-msg---> channelGraphSyncer
---gossip-msgs---> gossiper
In this commit, we remove the ability for ActiveSync GossipSyncers to
synchronize our graph with our remote peers. This serves as a starting
point towards allowing the daemon to only synchronize our graph through
historical syncs, which will be routinely done by the SyncManager.
This commit reduces the number of channels a syncer will request from
the remote node in a single QueryShortChanIDs message. The current size
is derived from the chunkSize, which is meant to signal the maximum
number of short chan ids that can fit in a single ReplyChannelRange
message. For EncodingSortedPlain, this number is 8000, and we use the
same number to dictate the size of the batch from the remote peer.
We modify this by introducing a separately configurable batchSize, so
that both can be tuned independently. The value is chosen to reduce the
amount of buffering the remote party will perform, only requiring them
queue 500 responses, as opposed to 8000. In turn, this reduces larges
spikes in allocation on the remote node at the expense of a few extra
round trips for the control messages. However, will be negligible since
the control messages are much smaller than the messages being returned.
In this commit, we introduce another feature to the GossipSyncer in
which it can deliver a signal to an external caller once it reaches its
terminal chansSynced state. This is yet to be used, but will serve
useful with a round-robin sync mechanism, where we wait for to finish
syncing with a specific peer before moving on to the next.
In this commit, we introduce the ability for gossip syncers to perform
historical syncs. This allows us to reconcile any channels we're missing
that the remote peer has starting from the genesis block of the chain.
This commit serves as a prerequisite to the SyncManager, introduced in a
later commit, where we'll be able to make spot checks by performing
historical syncs with peers to ensure we have as much of the graph as
possible.
In this commit, we introduce the ability for GossipSyncer's to
transition their sync type. This allows us to be more flexible with our
gossip syncers, as we can now prevent them from receiving new graph
updates at any time. It's now possible to transition between the
different sync types, as long as the GossipSyncer has reached its
terminal chansSynced sync state. Certain transitions require some
additional wire messages to be sent, like in the case of an ActiveSync
GossipSyncer transitioning to a PassiveSync type.
In this commit, we introduce a new type: SyncerType. This type denotes
the type of sync a GossipSyncer is currently under. We only introduce
the two possible entry states, ActiveSync and PassiveSync. An ActiveSync
GossipSyncer will exchange channels with the remote peer and receive new
graph updates from them, while a PassiveSync GossipSyncer will not and
will only response to the remote peer's queries.
This commit does not modify the behavior and is only meant to be a
refactor.
In this commit, we allow the gossiper syncer to store the chunk size for
its respective encoding type. We do this to prevent a race condition
that would arise within the unit tests by modifying the values of the
encodingTypeToChunkSize map to allow for easier testing.
This new method allows outside callers to sample the current state of
the gossipSyncer in a concurrent-safe manner. In order to achieve this,
we now only modify the g.state variable atomically.
In this commit, introduce a new struct, the gossipSyncer. The role of
this struct is to encapsulate the state machine required to implement
the new gossip query range feature recently added to the spec. With this
change, each peer that knows of this new feature will have a new
goroutine that will be managed by the gossiper.
Once created and started, the gossipSyncer will start to progress
through each possible state, finally ending at the chansSynced stage. In
this stage, it has synchronized state with the remote peer, and is
simply awaiting any new messages from the gossiper to send directly to
the peer. Each message will only be sent if the remote peer actually has
a set update horizon, and the message isn't before or after that
horizon.
A set of unit tests has been added to ensure that two state machines
properly terminate and synchronize channel state.
