The unit test TestNewBreachRetributionSkipsDustHtlcs triggered a state
transition from Bob, even though it was Alice that had added the HTLCs.
This is wrong since it will lead to Bob still owing Alice a commitment,
which is not accounted for in the unit tests.
We add a sanity check that the add heights has been set for all entries
found in the logs, and return an error otherwise. This won't happen
during normal operation, but it does reveal the mistake in the unit
test, which is fixed by making Alice trigger the transition.
In addition we resolve a long standing TODO by removing a (purposeful)
panic in the channel state machine. Old version of lnd had a bug that
could lead to the parent entries being lost during channel restore. A
panic was added to get to the bottom of if.
This is now fixed, so new nodes shouldn't encounter it. However, to be
on the safe side, instead of panicking we return an error back to
gracefully exit the channel state machine.
Updates were always restored with the same log index. This could cause a
crash when the logs were compacted and possibly other problems
elsewhere.
Extended unit test to cover the crash scenario.
This commit updates the channel state machine to
persistently store remote updates that we have received a
signature for, but that we haven't yet included in a commit
signature of our own.
Previously those updates were only stored in memory and
dropped across restarts. This lead to the production of
an invalid signature and channel force closure. The remote
party expects us to include those updates.
When creating the keyring, the tweak is already calculated in the remote
commitment case. We add the calculation also for our own commitment, so
we can use it in all cases without deriving the tweak.
Based on the current channel type, we derive the script used for the
to_remote output. Currently only the unencumbered p2wkh type is used,
but that will change with upcoming channel types.
To make the channel state machine less concerned about the type of
commitment, we nil the local tweak when creating the keyring, depending
on the commitment type.
We abstract away how keys are generated for the different channel types
types (currently tweak(less)).
Intention is that more of the logic that is unique for each commitment
type lives in commitment.go, making the channel state machine oblivious
to the keys and outputs being created on the commitment tx for a given
channel state.
createCommitmentTx would earlier mutate the passed commitment struct
after evaluating the htlc view and calculating the final balances, which
was confusing since the balances are supposed to only be *after*
subtracting fees.
Instead we take the needed parameters as arguments, and return the final
balances, tx and fee to populate the commitment struct in a proper way.
PURE CODE MOVE:
Moving createCommitmentTx, CreateCommitTx, createStateHintObfuscator,
CommitmentKeyRing, DeriveCommitmentKeys, addHTLC, genHtlcScripts
We move the methods and structs to a new file commitment.go in
preparation for defining all the logic that is dependent on the channel
type in this new file.
Instead of passing delays and dustlimits separately, we pass the correct
channel config to CreateCommitTx from the POV of the local party that
owns the commit tx.
To make it more clear which commitment we are actually creating, we
rename variables to denote local and remote, to prepare for the case
when both outputs might be delayed.
This commit adds fields for upfront shutdown scripts set
by the local and remote peer to the OpenChannel struct.
These values are optional, so they are added with their
own keys in the chanBucket in the DB.
This commit sets our close addresss to the address
specified by option upfront shutdown, if specified,
and disconnects from peers that fail to provide
their upfront shutdown address for coopertaive closes
of channels that were opened with the option set.
Instead of tracking local updates in a separate link variable, query
this state from the channel itself.
This commit also fixes the issue where the commit tx was not updated
anymore after a failed first attempt because the revocation window was
closed. Also those pending updates will be taken into account when the
remote party revokes.
Previously the channel method FullySynced was used to decide whether to
send a new commit sig message. However, it could happen that FullySynced
was false, but that we didn't owe a commitment signature. Instead we
were waiting on the other party to send us a signature. If that
happened, we'd send out an empty commit sig. This commit modifies the
condition that triggers a new commit sig and fixes this deviation from
the spec.
To facilitate the logging, this commit adds a new OweCommitment method.
For the logging, we only need to consider the remote perspective. In a
later commit, we'll also start using the local perspective to support
the decision to send another signature.
In this commit, we create a new chainfee package, that houses all fee
related functionality used within the codebase. The creation of this new
package furthers our long-term goal of extracting functionality from the
bloated `lnwallet` package into new distinct packages. Additionally,
this new packages resolves a class of import cycle that could arise if a
new package that was imported by something in `lnwallet` wanted to use
the existing fee related functions in the prior `lnwallet` package.
In this commit, we convert the existing `channeldb.ChannelType` type
into a _bit field_. This doesn't require us to change the current
serialization or interpretation or the type as it is, since all the
current defined values us a distinct bit. This PR lays the ground work
for any future changes that may introduce new channel types (like anchor
outputs), and also any changes that may modify the existing invariants
around channels (if we're the initiator, we always have the funding
transaction).
Without this, it was possible for a combination of our balance and max
fee allocation to result in a fee rate below the fee floor causing the
remote party to reject the update and close the channel.
In this commit, we move to make a full deep copy of the commitment
transaction in `getSignedCommitTx` to ensure that we don't mutate the
commitment on disk, possibly resulting in a "hot commitment".
In this commit, we consolidate the number of areas where we derive our
commitment keys. Before this commit, the `isOurCommitment` function in
the chain watcher used a custom routine to derive the expected
scripts/keys for our commitment at that height. With the recent changes,
we now have additional logic in `DeriveCommitmentKeys` that wasn't
copied over to this area. As a result, the prior logic would erroneously
detect if it was our commitment that had hit the chain or not.
In this commit, we remove the old custom code, and use
`DeriveCommitmentKeys` wihtin the chain watcher as well. This ensures
that we only need to maintain the key derivation code in a single place,
preventing future bugs of this nature.
In this commit, we update the brar logic in the channel state machine,
and also the brar itself to be aware of the new commitment format.
Similar to the unilateral close summary, we'll now blank out the
SingleTweak field in `NewBreachRetribution` if it's a tweakless
commitment. The brar will then use this to properly identify the
commitment type, to ensure we use the proper witness generation function
when we're handling our own breach.
In this commit, we update the channel state machine to be aware of
tweakless commits. In several areas, we'll now check the channel's type
to see if it's `SingleFunderTweakless`. If so, then we'll opt to use the
remote party's non-delay based point directly in the script, skipping
any additional cryptographic operations. Along the way we move the
`validateCommitmentSanity` method to be defined _before_ it's used as is
cutomary within the codebase.
Notably, within the `NewUnilateralCloseSummary` method, we'll now _blank
out_ the `SingleTweak` value if the commitment is tweakless. This
indicates to callers the witness type they should map to, as the value
isn't needed at all any longer when sweeping a non-delay output.
We also update the signing+verification tests to also test that we're
able to properly generate a valid witness for the new tweakless
commitment format.
Instead of marking the database state when processing the channel
reestablishment message, we wait for the result of this processing to
arrive in the link, and mark it accordingly in the database here.
We do this move the logic determining whether we should force close the
channel or not, and what state to mark it in the DB, to the same place,
as these need to be consistent.
This commit converts the ErrCommitSyncLocalDataLoss error into a struct,
that also holds the received last unrevoked commit point from the remote
party.
In this commit, we fix a lingering TOOD statement in the channel arb.
Before this commitment, we would simply wipe our our local HTLC set of
the HTLC set that was on the remote commitment transaction on force
close. This was incorrect as if our commitment transaction had an HTLC
that the remote commitment didn't, then we would fail to cancel that
back, and cause both channels to time out on chain.
In order to remedy this, we introduce a new `HtlcSetKey` struct to track
all 3 possible in-flight set of HTLCs: ours, theirs, and their pending.
We also we start to tack on additional data to all the unilateral close
messages we send to subscribers. This new data is the CommitSet, or the
set of valid commitments at channel closure time. This new information
will be used by the channel arb in an upcoming commit to ensure it will
cancel back HTLCs in the case of split commitment state.
Finally, we start to thread through an optional *CommitSet to the
advanceState method. This additional information will give the channel
arb addition information it needs to ensure it properly cancels back
HTLCs that are about to time out or may time out depending on which
commitment is played.
Within the htlcswitch pakage, we modify the `SignNextCommitment` method
to return the new set of pending HTLCs for the remote party's commitment
transaction and `ReceiveRevocation` to return the latest set of
commitment transactions on the remote party's commitment as well. This
is a preparatory change which is part of a larger change to address a
lingering TODO in the cnct.
Additionally, rather than just send of the set of HTLCs after the we
revoke, we'll also send of the set of HTLCs after the remote party
revokes, and we create a pending commitment state for it.
Now that the success resolver preimage field is always populated by the
incoming contest resolver, preimage lookups earlier in the
process (channel and channel arbitrator) can mostly be removed.
In this commit, we modify the main `closeObserver` dispatch loop to only
look for the local force close if we didn't recover the channel. We do
this, as for a recovered channel, it isn't possible for us to force
close from a recovered channel.
In this commit, we modify the `ChanSyncMsg` to send an invalid
commitment secret in `ChanSyncMsg`. We do this in order to force the
remote party to force close off-chain, if we're restoring a channel from
scratch and we never had any state updates within the channel. We need
to do this, as otherwise the remote party will think we can resume as
they're able to verify their own commit secret for state zero.
In this commit, we set a default max HTLC in the forwarding
policies of newly open channels.
The ForwardingPolicy's MaxHTLC field (added in this commit)
will later be used to decide whether an HTLC satisfies our policy before
forwarding it.
To ensure the ForwardingPolicy's MaxHTLC default matches the max HTLC
advertised in the ChannelUpdate sent out for this channel, we also add
a MaxPendingAmount() function to the lnwallet.Channel.
This commit is a step to split the lnwallet package. It puts the Input
interface and implementations in a separate package along with all their
dependencies from lnwallet.
To avoid more bugs slipping through where the logIndex is not set, we
panic to catch this. This was earlier done for Adds and the htlcCounter,
which did lead us to find the resulting retoration bug.
Earlier versions did not write the log index to disk for fee updates, so
they will be unset. To account for this we set them to to current update
log index.
In this commit, we ensure that if a channel is detected to have local
data loss, then we don't allow a force close attempt, as this may not be
possible, or cause us to play an invalid state.
This commit removes the breach transaction from the
arguments passed to NewBreachRetribution. We already
keep all prior remote commitments on disk in the
commitment log, and load that transaction from disk
inside the method. In practice, the one loaded from
disk will be the same one that is passed in by the
caller, so there should be no change in behavior
as we've already derived the appropriate state number.
This changes makes integration with the watchtower
client simpler, since we no longer need to acquire
the breaching commitment transaction to be able to
construct the BreachRetribution. This simplifies
not only the logic surrounding transient backsups,
but also on startup (and later, retroactively
backing up historic updates).
Instead of special casing the UpdateFee messages, we instead add them to
the update logs like any other HTLC update message. This lets us avoid
having to keep an extra set of variables to keep track of the fee
updates, and instead reuse the commit/ack logic used for other updates.
This fixes a bug where we would reset the pendingFeeUpdate variable
after signing our next commitment, which would make us calculate the new
fee incorrectly if the remote sent a commitment concurrently.
When restoring state logs, we also make sure to re-add any fee updates.
When compacting the update logs we remove any fee updates when they
remove height is passed. We do this since we'll assume fee updates are
added and removed at the same commit height, as they will apply for all
commitments following the fee update.
This commit adds conversion between the lnwire.UpdateFee message and the
new FeeUpdate PaymentDescriptor. We re-purpose the existing Amount field
in the PaymentDescriptor stuct to hold the feerate.
This commit adds a new updateType that can be used for
PaymentDescriptors: FeeUpdate. We repurpose the fields of the existing
PaymentDescriptor struct such that we can easily re-use the commit/ack
logic used for other update types also for fee updates.
In this commit, we remove the per channel `sigPool` within the
`lnwallet.LightningChannel` struct. With this change, we ensure that as
the number of channels grows, the number of gouroutines idling in the
sigPool stays constant. It's the case that currently on the daemon, most
channels are likely inactive, with only a hand full actually
consistently carrying out channel updates. As a result, this change
should reduce the amount of idle CPU usage, as we have less active
goroutines in select loops.
In order to make this change, the `SigPool` itself has been publicly
exported such that outside callers can make a `SigPool` and pass it into
newly created channels. Since the sig pool now lives outside the
channel, we were also able to do away with the Stop() method on the
channel all together.
Finally, the server is the sub-system that is currently responsible for
managing the `SigPool` within lnd.
In this commit, we fix an existing bug wherein we wouldn't set the short
channel ID for the close summary in the database in the case that the
remote party force closed. The fix is simple, ensure that within
NewUnilateralCloseSummary we properly set the short channel ID. A test
has also been added in this commit, which fails without the
modifications to lnwallet/channel.go.
Fixes#2072.
In this commit, we fix a slight bug by ensuring that the revocation info
at the final state of the channel, as well as the local chan config is
properly set within the channel close summary created within
NewUnilateralCloseSummary. Before this commit, for all cooperative close
transactions, this state would _only_ include the pubkey itself, which
in some cases may not be sufficient to re-derive the key if needed.
In this commit, we update the NewBreachRetribution method to include
pkScripts for htlc outputs. We do this now, as the breach arbiter will
need the raw pkScript when attempting to request spend notifications for
each HTLC.
In this commit, we export WitnessScriptHash and GenMultiSigScript as
external sub-systems may now need to use these methods in order to be
able to watch for confirmations based on the script of a transaction.
This commit adds a check for the LocalUnrevokedCommitPoint sent to us by
the remote during channel reestablishment, ensuring it is the same point
as they have previously sent us.
This commit enumerates the various error cases we can encounter when we
compare our remote commit chain to the view the remote communicates to us
via msg.NextLocalCommitHeight.
We now compare this height to our remote tail and tip height, returning
relevant error in case of a unrecoverable desync, and re-send a
commitment signature (including log updates) in case we owe one.
This commit enumerates the various error cases we can encounter when we
compare our local commit chain to the view the remote communicates to us
via msg.RemoteCommitTailHeight.
We now compare this height to our local tail height (note that there's
never a local "tip" at this point), returning relevant error in case of
a unrecoverable desync, and re-send a revocation in case we owe one.
This commit defines a few new errors that we can potentially encounter
during channel reestablishment:
* ErrInvalidLocalUnrevokedCommitPoint
* ErrCommitSyncLocalDataLoss
* ErrCommitSyncRemoteDataLoss
in addition to the already defined errors
* ErrInvalidLastCommitSecret
* ErrCannotSyncCommitChains
