discovery: use token bucket based rate limiting to throttle gossip

The recently added gossip throttling was shown to be too aggressive,
especially with our auto channel enable/disable signaling. We switch to
a token bucket based system instead as it's based on time, rather than a
block height which isn't constantly updated at a given rate.

discovery/gossiper.go

@@ -22,6 +22,19 @@ import (
 	"github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/routing"
 	"github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/routing/route"
 	"github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/ticker"
+	"golang.org/x/time/rate"
+)
+
+const (
+	// DefaultMaxChannelUpdateBurst is the default maximum number of updates
+	// for a specific channel and direction that we'll accept over an
+	// interval.
+	DefaultMaxChannelUpdateBurst = 10
+
+	// DefaultChannelUpdateInterval is the default interval we'll use to
+	// determine how often we should allow a new update for a specific
+	// channel and direction.
+	DefaultChannelUpdateInterval = time.Minute
 )
 
 var (
@@ -237,6 +250,15 @@ type Config struct {
 	// ActiveSync upon connection. These peers will never transition to
 	// PassiveSync.
 	PinnedSyncers PinnedSyncers
+
+	// MaxChannelUpdateBurst specifies the maximum number of updates for a
+	// specific channel and direction that we'll accept over an interval.
+	MaxChannelUpdateBurst int
+
+	// ChannelUpdateInterval specifies the interval we'll use to determine
+	// how often we should allow a new update for a specific channel and
+	// direction.
+	ChannelUpdateInterval time.Duration
 }
 
 // AuthenticatedGossiper is a subsystem which is responsible for receiving
@@ -313,12 +335,14 @@ type AuthenticatedGossiper struct {
 	// network.
 	reliableSender *reliableSender
 
-	// heightForLastChanUpdate keeps track of the height at which we
+	// chanUpdateRateLimiter contains rate limiters for each direction of
-	// processed the latest channel update for a specific direction.
+	// a channel update we've processed. We'll use these to determine
+	// whether we should accept a new update for a specific channel and
+	// direction.
 	//
 	// NOTE: This map must be synchronized with the main
 	// AuthenticatedGossiper lock.
-	heightForLastChanUpdate map[uint64][2]uint32
+	chanUpdateRateLimiter map[uint64][2]*rate.Limiter
 
 	sync.Mutex
 }
@@ -335,7 +359,7 @@ func New(cfg Config, selfKey *btcec.PublicKey) *AuthenticatedGossiper {
 		prematureChannelUpdates: make(map[uint64][]*networkMsg),
 		channelMtx:              multimutex.NewMutex(),
 		recentRejects:           make(map[uint64]struct{}),
-		heightForLastChanUpdate: make(map[uint64][2]uint32),
+		chanUpdateRateLimiter:   make(map[uint64][2]*rate.Limiter),
 	}
 
 	gossiper.syncMgr = newSyncManager(&SyncManagerCfg{
@@ -1950,21 +1974,32 @@ func (d *AuthenticatedGossiper) processNetworkAnnouncement(
 					return nil
 				}
 			} else {
-				// If it's not, we'll only allow a single update
+				// If it's not, we'll allow an update per minute
-				// for this channel per block.
+				// with a maximum burst of 10. If we haven't
+				// seen an update for this channel before, we'll
+				// need to initialize a rate limiter for each
+				// direction.
 				d.Lock()
-				lastUpdateHeight := d.heightForLastChanUpdate[shortChanID]
+				rateLimiters, ok := d.chanUpdateRateLimiter[shortChanID]
-				if lastUpdateHeight[direction] == d.bestHeight {
+				if !ok {
-					log.Debugf("Ignoring update for "+
+					r := rate.Every(d.cfg.ChannelUpdateInterval)
-						"channel %v due to previous "+
+					b := d.cfg.MaxChannelUpdateBurst
-						"update occurring within the "+
+					rateLimiters = [2]*rate.Limiter{
-						"same block %v", shortChanID,
+						rate.NewLimiter(r, b),
-						d.bestHeight)
+						rate.NewLimiter(r, b),
-					d.Unlock()
+					}
+					d.chanUpdateRateLimiter[shortChanID] = rateLimiters
+				}
+				d.Unlock()
+
+				if !rateLimiters[direction].Allow() {
+					log.Debugf("Rate limiting update for "+
+						"channel %v from direction %x",
+						shortChanID,
+						pubKey.SerializeCompressed())
 					nMsg.err <- nil
 					return nil
 				}
-				d.Unlock()
 			}
 		}
 
@@ -2011,15 +2046,6 @@ func (d *AuthenticatedGossiper) processNetworkAnnouncement(
 			return nil
 		}
 
-		// With the edge successfully updated on disk, we'll note the
-		// current height so that we're able to rate limit any future
-		// updates for the same channel.
-		d.Lock()
-		lastUpdateHeight := d.heightForLastChanUpdate[shortChanID]
-		lastUpdateHeight[direction] = d.bestHeight
-		d.heightForLastChanUpdate[shortChanID] = lastUpdateHeight
-		d.Unlock()
-
 		// If this is a local ChannelUpdate without an AuthProof, it
 		// means it is an update to a channel that is not (yet)
 		// supposed to be announced to the greater network. However,

discovery/gossiper_test.go

@@ -733,19 +733,21 @@ func createTestCtx(startHeight uint32) (*testCtx, func(), error) {
 				Timestamp: testTimestamp,
 			}, nil
 		},
-		Router:               router,
+		Router:                router,
-		TrickleDelay:         trickleDelay,
+		TrickleDelay:          trickleDelay,
-		RetransmitTicker:     ticker.NewForce(retransmitDelay),
+		RetransmitTicker:      ticker.NewForce(retransmitDelay),
-		RebroadcastInterval:  rebroadcastInterval,
+		RebroadcastInterval:   rebroadcastInterval,
-		ProofMatureDelta:     proofMatureDelta,
+		ProofMatureDelta:      proofMatureDelta,
-		WaitingProofStore:    waitingProofStore,
+		WaitingProofStore:     waitingProofStore,
-		MessageStore:         newMockMessageStore(),
+		MessageStore:          newMockMessageStore(),
-		RotateTicker:         ticker.NewForce(DefaultSyncerRotationInterval),
+		RotateTicker:          ticker.NewForce(DefaultSyncerRotationInterval),
-		HistoricalSyncTicker: ticker.NewForce(DefaultHistoricalSyncInterval),
+		HistoricalSyncTicker:  ticker.NewForce(DefaultHistoricalSyncInterval),
-		NumActiveSyncers:     3,
+		NumActiveSyncers:      3,
-		AnnSigner:            &mock.SingleSigner{Privkey: nodeKeyPriv1},
+		AnnSigner:             &mock.SingleSigner{Privkey: nodeKeyPriv1},
-		SubBatchDelay:        time.Second * 5,
+		SubBatchDelay:         time.Second * 5,
-		MinimumBatchSize:     10,
+		MinimumBatchSize:      10,
+		MaxChannelUpdateBurst: DefaultMaxChannelUpdateBurst,
+		ChannelUpdateInterval: DefaultChannelUpdateInterval,
 	}, nodeKeyPub1)
 
 	if err := gossiper.Start(); err != nil {
@@ -3938,6 +3940,8 @@ func TestRateLimitChannelUpdates(t *testing.T) {
 	}
 	defer cleanup()
 	ctx.gossiper.cfg.RebroadcastInterval = time.Hour
+	ctx.gossiper.cfg.MaxChannelUpdateBurst = 5
+	ctx.gossiper.cfg.ChannelUpdateInterval = 5 * time.Second
 
 	// The graph should start empty.
 	require.Empty(t, ctx.router.infos)
@@ -4036,24 +4040,40 @@ func TestRateLimitChannelUpdates(t *testing.T) {
 
 	// Then, we'll move on to the non keep alive cases.
 	//
-	// Non keep alive updates are limited to one per block per direction.
+	// For this test, non keep alive updates are rate limited to one per 5
-	// Since we've already processed updates for both sides, the new updates
+	// seconds with a max burst of 5 per direction. We'll process the max
-	// for both directions will not be broadcast until a new block arrives.
+	// burst of one direction first. None of these should be rate limited.
 	updateSameDirection := keepAliveUpdate
+	for i := uint32(0); i < uint32(ctx.gossiper.cfg.MaxChannelUpdateBurst); i++ {
+		updateSameDirection.Timestamp++
+		updateSameDirection.BaseFee++
+		require.NoError(t, signUpdate(nodeKeyPriv1, &updateSameDirection))
+		assertRateLimit(&updateSameDirection, nodePeer1, false)
+	}
+
+	// Following with another update should be rate limited as the max burst
+	// has been reached and we haven't ticked at the next interval yet.
 	updateSameDirection.Timestamp++
 	updateSameDirection.BaseFee++
 	require.NoError(t, signUpdate(nodeKeyPriv1, &updateSameDirection))
 	assertRateLimit(&updateSameDirection, nodePeer1, true)
 
+	// An update for the other direction should not be rate limited.
 	updateDiffDirection := *batch.chanUpdAnn2
 	updateDiffDirection.Timestamp++
 	updateDiffDirection.BaseFee++
 	require.NoError(t, signUpdate(nodeKeyPriv2, &updateDiffDirection))
-	assertRateLimit(&updateDiffDirection, nodePeer2, true)
-
-	// Notify a new block and reprocess the updates. They should no longer
-	// be rate limited.
-	ctx.notifier.notifyBlock(chainhash.Hash{}, blockHeight+1)
-	assertRateLimit(&updateSameDirection, nodePeer1, false)
 	assertRateLimit(&updateDiffDirection, nodePeer2, false)
+
+	// Wait for the next interval to tick. Since we've only waited for one,
+	// only one more update is allowed.
+	<-time.After(ctx.gossiper.cfg.ChannelUpdateInterval)
+	for i := 0; i < ctx.gossiper.cfg.MaxChannelUpdateBurst; i++ {
+		updateSameDirection.Timestamp++
+		updateSameDirection.BaseFee++
+		require.NoError(t, signUpdate(nodeKeyPriv1, &updateSameDirection))
+
+		shouldRateLimit := i != 0
+		assertRateLimit(&updateSameDirection, nodePeer1, shouldRateLimit)
+	}
 }